Reviews
My Sister's Keeper
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Nick Cassavetes |
Written by: | Jeremy Leven, Nick Cassavetes |
Starring: | Cameron Diaz, Abigail Breslin, Sofia Vassilieva, Jason Patric, Alec Baldwin, Joan Cusack |
Released: | July 30, 2009 |
Grade: | A- |
I saw My Sister’s Keeper in a fairly packed cinema and as the closing credits started to roll, the lady seated to my left, who was a complete stranger, apologised for her crying and blubbering. Even my eyes were a little moist. It’s just that kind of film.
Based on the novel by Jodi Picoult, I realised early on that this movie was something different. Anna Fitzgerald (Breslin) is an 11-year-old girl who was brought into this world for an unusual reason. Anna’s older sister, Kate (Vassilieva), was diagnosed with leukaemia at a very early age. With no compatible donors in the family to supply bone marrow, Sara and Brian Fitzgerald (Diaz and Patric) made the decision to have another child. Anna was hence created from a test tube using Kate’s DNA.
For as long as she can remember, Anna herself has undergone numerous medical procedures to help Kate. She loves her family very much but Anna is tiring of the burden that she carries. She wants to live a normal existence. Anna’s true feelings are revealed when asked to donate one of her kidneys to her gravely ill sister. Anna knows that being one kidney short will affect the quality of her life going forward. She also realises that the transplant may not even work.
Where does one draw the line in this situation? It’s a tough choice for an adult yet alone a scared 11-year-old. Anna approaches a high-profile lawyer named Campbell Alexander (Baldwin) and asks that he help her become “medically emancipated” from her parents. She wants to be able to make her own decisions about her body and how it is used. It’s a decision that threatens to divide the family…
Unless you have the hardest of hearts, you’ll need something to wipe your eyes with during much of this film. Tissues are preferred. I think it’s a little too depressing at times with its sad songs and down-beat storyline but that’s my only major qualm. I was really moved by this tale and the quality of the performances.
I hadn’t heard of her before but 16-year-old Sofia Vassilieva (Medium) turns in one of the bravest performances that I’ve seen from a child actor. She is very sick for much of the film and it’s tough to watch her throwing up and enduring savage nose bleeds. Even tougher is seeing her reflect on her life knowing in the back of her head that she may not have much longer. If I were a member of the Academy, I’d be putting her first on my ballot for best supporting actress.
The whole cast is impressive. There’s a beautiful scene involving Abigail Breslin (the young girl from Little Miss Sunshine) and the wonderful Joan Cusack (In & Out), who plays the judge at Anna’s hearing. The two have a one-in-one in the judge’s chambers where they discuss Anna’s decision and the judge’s own daughter. To quickly name a few more… Cameron Diaz (What Happens In Vegas) is terrific as the over-zealous mother and Jason Patric (Sleepers) is excellent in his performance as the subdued father.
You should be forewarned that My Sister’s Keeper is heavy going. You’ll be put through the emotional wringer. It’s one of the real surprises of the year for me and I recommend it highly.
Public Enemies
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Michael Mann |
Written by: | Ronan Bennett, Michael Mann, Ann Biderman |
Starring: | Johnny Depp, Christian Bale, Marion Cotillard, Billy Crudup, David Wenham, Giovanni Ribisi |
Released: | July 30, 2009 |
Grade: | A- |
In 1924, 21-year-old John Dillinger was sentenced to jail for mugging a grocer. It was his first offence but the judge threw the book at him. Dillinger would serve eight and half years behind bars. On his release in 1933, Dillinger was anything but reformed. He put together a “tough as guts” crew and instigated a barrage of robberies across the United States. Infamous he would become.
This final year in the life of John Dillinger is the subject of Michael Mann’s new film. It may be set in the midst of the Great Depression but Mann didn’t want it to feel like a period piece. With the help of cinematographer Dante Spinotti (L.A. Confidential), Mann has shot the movie using the latest in digital cameras. It gives the film a crisp, fresh look.
I’ve always held Michael Mann in high regard. He knows how to bring a story to life and previous credits include Heat, The Insider and Collateral. Much research went into this project. He wanted to retell the Dillinger story as accurately as possible. This included a detailed review of files in the FBI archives. He also created 114 different sets and shot several scenes in the exact same location where actual events took place.
John Dillinger (played in the film by Johnny Depp) may have been the most wanted man in the United States but many people saw him as a hero. His dictum was never to rob from ordinary people – he just wanted to punish the banks and the government for their roles in the lead up to the Great Depression. You’ll learn pretty quickly that Dillinger was a guy who lived for today and not for tomorrow. He knew his escapades would not last and he wanted to make the most of his notoriety.
What I found more interesting that Dillinger’s escapades was the chase by the authorities to capture him. The newly formed FBI was using their best men to hunt down Dillinger and his crew. Leading the chase was a young agent out to impress by the name of Melvin Purvis (played by Christian Bale). Equal waiting is given in the film to the stories of both Dillinger and Purvis.
I didn’t realise it before seeing Public Enemies but the 1930s were a curious era in law enforcement. Outlaws such as Dillinger could now use cars to escape. They also had huge machine guns which could fire a seemingly endless stream of bullets… not too accurately I might add. To try to peg back the upper hand, the authorities used the latest forensic techniques, such as fingerprinting.
There are some great shoot-outs in this film to appease the action fans. It’s reminiscent of Michael Mann’s work in Heat, except that the guns are about 60 years older. Johnny Depp is solid in the leading role but it was the supporting players who grabbed my attention. Christian Bale is terrific as Mevlin Purvis as is French actress Marion Cotillard (La Vie En Rose) who plays Dillinger’s girlfriend, Billie Frechette.
Clocking in at just under two and a half hours, Public Enemies makes for good viewing and is a refreshing change from the special effects laden sequels which are currently clogging up our multiplexes.
Harry Potter & The Half-Blood Prince
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | David Yates |
Written by: | Steve Cloves |
Starring: | Daniel Radcliffe, Michael Gambon, Jim Broadbent, Rupert Grint, Emma Watson, Bonnie Wright, Helena Bonham Carter, Alan Rickman, Tom Felton |
Released: | July 15, 2009 |
Grade: | B- |
On a sunny morning in July 2005, I lined up outside the Victoria Palace Theatre in London for tickets to see Billy Elliot: The Musical. I arrived at 8:30am and had to wait three and a half hours for the ticket counter to open.
The time flew by however because in my hands was a copy of the recently released Harry Potter & The Half-Blood Prince. Totally engrossed, I read each page quicker than the last, anxiously waiting to find out what was in store for Harry and his friends.
Last night, I saw the cinematic adaptation of this book. Let’s just say that my level of excitement was not even close to that which I experienced four years ago. Something major has been lost in translating J.K. Rowling’s sixth Harry Potter book to the big screen.
There’s a noticeable lack of action, a lack of suspense. Some characters are woefully underdeveloped and too much emphasis is placed on the story’s romantic elements. This is the worst film in the series to date.
In this much darker adventure, Harry (Radcliffe) and his fellow students have returned to Hogwarts School with trepidation. The evil Lord Voldemort has returned (see the fifth film for more information) and wizarding world are bracing themselves for another attack. Nowhere is safe.
The school’s headmaster, Professor Dumbledore (Gambon), knows that Voldemort’s power is increasing. He must be stopped before it is too late. Dumbledore reluctantly asks for Harry’s help and provides information on how Voldemort came to be. As a child, Voldemort was one of Hogwart’s most gifted students but there was always something different about him. He had an insatiable thirst for the dark arts.
Dumbledore believes that the key to destroying Voldemort lies with an old friend, Professor Horace Slughorn (Broadbent). He has invited the Professor to teach potions at Hogwarts this year… not because he is a great teacher but because Dumbledore seeks something from him. Harry will be instrumental in Dumbledore’s plan.
As a backdrop to this main storyline, there are number of light-hearted, romantic subplots. Love maybe in the air but Cupid’s arrows seem to be off the mark. Harry likes Ginny but is too afraid to admit it. The same goes for Ron and Hermoine who both find themselves entangled with a not-so-perfect match.
I wasn’t bored by Harry Potter & The Half-Blood Prince but I think that these movies have lost their sparkle. Director David Yates, who also made the last film, hasn’t left much of a signature. There’s nothing new, nothing fresh. Nicholas Hooper’s film score is dull and the special effects were anything but. Scenes were included for reasons unbeknown to me. Why even show the Quidditch match?
As disenchanted as I felt, there are elements of the film to enjoy. The underrated Jim Broadbent (Iris, Topsy-Turvy) is terrific as Professor Slughorn. Daniel Radcliffe has a humorous few moments after drinking a special tonic which brings good luck. It was good to see him liven up and it took the edge off the otherwise depressing story.
The final book, Harry Potter & The Deathly Hallows, will be split into two movies – one released in 2010 and the other in 2011. I’m disappointed to hear that director David Yates will be at the helm for both flicks. Hopefully he will lift his game or else this much anticipated series will slip away into antiquity.
Chéri
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Stephen Frears |
Written by: | Christopher Hampton |
Starring: | Michelle Pfeiffer, Kathy Bates, Rupert Friend, Felicity Jones, Frances Tomelty |
Released: | July 23, 2009 |
Grade: | A- |
A mix of both comedy and drama, Chéri is a delightful romantic flick that left me grinning from ear to ear. It is based on the novel from author Sidonie-Gabrielle Colette and comes with an edgy storyline and witty dialogue. They are two valued ingredients in my book.
Set in the early 20th Century, Lea de Lonval (Pfeiffer) is a retired courtesan living in Paris. She has a comfortable lifestyle and she spends most of her days socialising with friends. One such acquaintance is Madame Peloux (Bates), a formal rival in the courtesan business.
Madame Peloux has a 19-year-old son named Chéri (Friend), who up until this point has lived a life of debauchery. Chéri has always had a soft spot for Lea and after spending some time together, the pair find themselves in a relationship.
Yes, there is a huge age difference but neither seems to care. They are an ideal fit. Chéri draws on Lea’s maturity and easy-going nature. Lea draws on Chéri’s youth and exuberance. In all they would spend six very happy years together.
Unfortunately, it is something that cannot last and this is where the dramatic elements of the film take hold. Madame Peloux has arranged for Chéri to be married. She has found a suitably wealthy candidate and the wheels are in motion.
Neither Lea nor Chéri wish to be parted but neither has the courage to stand up and fight. Lea tries to convince herself that this was inevitable. Chéri was always going to leave her eventually and find a much younger someone with whom he could start a family. Chéri doesn’t want to upset his overbearing mother and goes along with the arrangement to keep her satisfied.
What will become of this divided duo? Can they bury their grief and move on with their lives? Or will their bond be too difficult to break? I don’t want to reveal too much but let me say that the final scene in this film is the best ending to a film I’ve seen all year. It’s bold, it’s risky and it’s shocking. I loved it.
Where has Michelle Pfeiffer been of late? According to the Internet Movie Database, this is only her 8th film in the past 10 years. You’d think that someone of her talent would have landed more roles. Perhaps she’s been choosy with her projects? When you see her in Chéri you’ll be reminded about how enchanting she can be. Kathy Bates also deserves a tick as Madame Peloux.
This is wonderful film headed by two experienced guys who know how to tell a good story. Stephens Frears directed The Queen, Mrs Henderson Presents and High Fidelity. Christopher Hampton adapted the screenplays for Atonement and The Quiet American. Together, they have crafted a sumptuous cinematic feast.
My Life In Ruins
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Donald Petrie |
Written by: | Mike Reiss |
Starring: | Nia Vardalos, Richard Dreyfuss, Alexis Georgoulis, Alistair McGowan, Harland Williams, Caroline Goodall |
Released: | July 16, 2009 |
Grade: | B |
Ever gone on an overseas holiday with a tour company? If so, did you have a funny, helpful tour guide? Or did you have a dull, boring one? Georgia (Vardalos) falls into the later category. She’s an American stuck working as a guide in Greece. It’s not her dream job and that shows with her level of enthusiasm. She’s constantly annoyed by her fussy customers and their lack of interest in Greek history. All they seem to care about is shopping and ice cream.
Things are about to change however. Her latest tour, which she thinks will be her last, will turn out to be a wild adventure. Central to it all is an elderly man named Irv (Dreyfuss) who gives Georgia some much needed advice. He tells her to lighten up and start appreciating the greatness of life. It gets even better for Georgia when she starts falling in love with her new, young bus driver (Georgoulis).
I didn’t think I’d be a huge fan of this movie but it’s heart-warming and sentimental. Sure it’s corny in places but Nia Vardalos (who we all remember from My Big Fat Greek Wedding) is a likeable heroine. I wanted her to find the happiness that she deserved.
Richard Dreyfuss (Mr. Holland’s Opus, The American President) was my favourite of the large cast. Dreyfuss is a wonderful actor and it’s a shame we don’t see him in more films these days. He and Vardalos share some nice moments together.
Released in the same week as new Harry Potter movie, My Life In Ruins won’t be the most popular flick at the box-office but it’s good to see a decent alternative to those not interested in wizards and muggles.
Drag Me To Hell
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Sam Raimi |
Written by: | Sam Raimi, Ivan Raimi |
Starring: | Alison Lohman, Justin Long, Lorna Raver, Dileep Rao, David Paymer, Adriana Barraza |
Released: | July 23, 2009 |
Grade: | A- |
Drag Me To Hell is the best horror film I’ve seen in some time. It caught me completely off guard and I wasn’t remotely interested in seeing it after a long day at work. It certainly “brightened up” my evening.
Christine Brown (Lohman) is a sweet, young girl who works as a bank loan officer. She is keeping a very close eye on the vacant Assistant Manager’s desk. It’s down to Christine and her compatriot to see who will earn the much valued promotion. She’s doing whatever she can to impress the boss.
She will be put to the test when a hideous old lady walks up to her desk. Her name is Sylvia Ganush (Raver) and she pleads to be given an extension on her mortgage payments. She has owned the home for 30 years and has only fallen behind due to recent illness. Christine is sympathetic but she denies Sylvia’s request. She doesn’t want to be seen as being soft.
Now, it starts to get interesting. Sylvia places a curse on Christine and leaves her with an ominous warning – “soon it will be you who comes begging to me.” I’ll have to use that line when I next speak with my own bank.
It turns out that Sylvia does have the ability to conjure up an evil spirit. Christine is soon visited by nasty paranormal being which leaves her well and truly shaken up. Unable to call the Ghostbusters, she relies on a local fortune teller for advice. He believes that the devil will be coming for her soul in three days time. She must find a way to fend off satin before it’s too late.
For the horror genre, Drag Me To Hell offers everything that you’re looking for. It has moments which will leave you jumping, moments that will leave you squirming and moments that will leave you chuckling. One of its strongest attributes is that it doesn’t take itself too seriously.
Sam Raimi also deserves credit for both his direction and his screenplay. This is another positive on his strong resume which includes The Evil Dead, A Simple Plan and the Spider-Man trilogy. With the help of cinematographer Peter Deming (Mulholland Dr.), he has created some particularly memorable scenes. One in particular involves Christine looking at a floating handkerchief while waiting in the car park. That’s all I can say.
I’ve sung the praises of Alison Lohman before in films such as Matchstick Men and White Oleander. It’s hard to believe that she turns 30 years of age this September – she looks much younger. She’s terrific in this film which sees her go through the full gamut of emotions. Lohman was only cast in the role after Juno’s Ellen Page had to withdraw due to a scheduling conflict.
I can’t finish up without mentioning Loran Raver’s small part as the ghastly Sylvia Ganush. What a memorable character. If I have nightmares tonight, then she’s the reason!