Reviews
The Waiting City
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Claire McCarthy |
Written by: | Claire McCarthy |
Starring: | Radha Mitchell, Joel Edgerton, Samrat Chakrabarti, Isabel Lucas, Tanushree Shankhar |
Released: | July 15, 2010 |
Grade: | B |
I guess Australian director Claire McCarthy likes a challenge. Instead of shooting her first major film in the comfort of her own country, she’s travelled to India to bring a very personal story to the big screen. The profiles of Joel Edgerton (Animal Kingdom) and Radha Mitchell (Finding Neverland) will help lure audiences but the reality is that this film has been made with a predominantly Indian cast and crew.
It’s the story of Fiona (Mitchell) and Ben (Edgerton), an Australian couple who have travelled to India to adopt a child. They’ve been waiting a long time and on arriving in India, they learn that their wait is going to continue for a few more days. There’s a delay with the paperwork and they’re forced to sit in their hotel room while waiting for news.
You’d think this would be a happy time for Ben and Fiona but not so. Their relationship is showing signs of strain. The Indian heat and Fiona’s lost luggage are doing little to help the situation. You’ll start to wonder if adopting a child is the best thing for this couple. Are they doing it because they think it’ll bring them back together?
To its credit, the film goes down some paths that you might not expect. I do like a movie which offers a few surprises. I’m sure many will be affected the spiritual elements which come through in the final third. I also enjoyed the developing friendship between Fiona and an Indian porter (Chakrabarti) who works at their hotel. They come from completely different backgrounds but they have much to share.
On the flip side, I struggled to understand what point writer-director Claire McCarthy is trying to make when it comes to adopting children from other countries. There’s one part of the film where she travels to her adopted child’s home village but nothing really comes of it.
I asked Radha Mitchell about this while hosting a question and answer session at the Brisbane premiere. Her stance was that it’s better to have a mother than not have one. She’d rather these children find a home in Australian than forever remain in an orphanage in India. It’s a valid argument but it doesn’t come through strongly enough in the film.
As I continue to point out, films like The Waiting City have a non-existent marketing budget and need all the help they can get to find an audience here in Australia. This isn’t the best Aussie film of the year but with strong performances and a distinct setting, it warrants your attention.
Knight And Day
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | James Mangold |
Written by: | Patrick O’Neill |
Starring: | Tom Cruise, Cameron Diaz, Peter Sarsgaard, Viola Davis, Paul Dano, Jordi Molla |
Released: | July 15, 2010 |
Grade: | C+ |
From the early scenes, I thought Knight And Day was an action spoof. How could it not be? The plot is so far-fetched that it makes Austin Powers look like an Oscar winning drama. If the film had of continued along these lines and thrown in a few laughs, I’d have been fine. My thumbs would be up.
As for the plot, it begins on an airport with June Havens (Diaz) bumping into a complete stranger. His name is Roy Miller (Cruise). They gaze into each other’s eyes, share some idle chit chat and then step on the same plane bound for Boston.
It will not reach its destination however. It turns out that Roy Miller is some kind of secret agent and that the plane is filled with bad guys out to get him. He kills them all (including the pilots) and then uses his expertise to land the plane in a field. As you’d expect, June is freaking out. There’s not much she can do though. Roy’s running this show and June is along for the ride… whether she likes it or not.
So what exactly is Roy trying to do? He has in his possession a top secret device which can create limitless energy. It turns out there’s a lot of people who want to get their hands on it. Over the next few days, this unlikely duo will find themselves in a ridiculous number of life-threatening situations. There’ll be shoot outs, there’ll be car chases and there’ll be government conspiracies. What else would you expect?
If you like your adrenalin pumping action movies then I’m sure there’s plenty here for you. I do believe more should have been made of the premise though. I got tired of all the gaps in the story – where characters suddenly wake up (after being drugged) and everything is fine. Was this meant to be a joke? If so, it was overused.
The most important part of this film though are the performances from the two lead actors – Tom Cruise and Cameron Diaz. If you like their characters and you like their sense of humour, I can safely say that you’re going to like the movie. I chuckled a few times but not nearly enough. I was fine with Diaz but I thought Cruise was trying way too hard. He’s wants to come across all suave and cool but I actually found him boring and one-dimensional. He’s also kind of creepy.
Knight And Day runs out of ammunition (unlike its characters) well before the closing credits start to roll.
Farewell
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Christian Carion |
Written by: | Christian Carion, Eric Raynaud |
Starring: | Emir Kusturica, Guillaume Canet, Alexandra Maria Lara, Ingeborga Dapkunaite, Aleksev Gorbunov |
Released: | July 1, 2010 |
Grade: | B+ |
I’ve always been intrigued by the world of espionage. There must be so much juicy stuff which goes on behind the closed doors of organisations like the CIA and MI6. There’d be stories of heroism and there’d be stories of betrayal. Most of these tales will never be told. They’ll remain locked away in top secret files which will never see the light of day.
Such secrecy only heightens our curiosity. There’s a significant percentage of the population who are drawn to novels written by the likes of Tom Clancy, Robert Ludlam and Dan Brown. How much of their work is inspired by the truth? Maybe it’s all just speculative fantasy? We’ll never really know.
Farewell is something a little different however. There’s a lot more truth to this than your average spy thriller. The screenwriters have drawn from the novel by Sergei Kostine and listened to hours of actual interviews with members of the French Secret Service. When word spread about the film being made, others came forward and gave their version of events under the condition of anonymity.
The story is set in the early 1980s in the midst of the Cold War. President Ronald Reagan was oblivious to the fact that United States intelligence had been infiltrated by Russian spies. The Russians were smuggling valuable information on matters such as the space program and nuclear weapons back home to the KGB. It gave them a valuable edge.
Two men would change the course of the history. To call them unlikely heroes would be an understatement. The first was a disillusioned KGB agent unhappy with the Soviet government. He was given the codename “Farewell”. The second was a French engineer working in Moscow. They weren’t trained spies and yet, they turned the tables on the KGB by smuggling its valuable secrets (including lists of spies) to the French Secret Service. A key alliance between the French and the United States would then be forged.
It’s this riveting story which makes Farewell a film worth seeing. The Cold War was an interesting period of history which hasn’t received much attention on the big screen (as opposed to World War II films). I shook my head in amazement at some scenes. How did these two guys manage to play such a big role in bringing down the Soviet empire?
French director Christian Carion (Joyeux Noel) struggles at time with the execution of the story. Some of the dialogue involving Ronald Reagan and his advisers is laughable. So too is the performance of Fred Ward as Reagan. That said, I was impressed by Emir Kusturica and Guillaume Canet in the leading roles. I slowly developed an emotional connection with both them and their families. I sat anxiously in my seat… hoping that no harm to come to them.
I always feel uneasy when filmmakers do this but yes, a few elements of the tale have been changed to assist with the cinematic adaptation. There were actually several French agents who helped “Farewell” sneak information out of Russia. Characters names have also been changed. I don’t think the Russian government was too impressed either as they denied Carion permission to film there. Carion did manage to get a few shots of Moscow though by pretending to film a Coca-Cola advertisement.
Featuring a mix of English, French and Russian, Farewell is a solid thriller.
The Hedgehog
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Mona Achache |
Written by: | Muriel Barbery |
Starring: | Josaine Balasko, Garance Le Guillermic, Togo Igawa, Anne Brochet, Ariane Ascaride, Wladimir Yordanoff |
Released: | July 8, 2010 |
Grade: | B |
The Hedgehog is a slightly offbeat French drama with three central characters. Paloma (Le Guillermic) is a 54-year-old janitor who services an apartment building filled with rich, well-to-do people. She seldom says a word and always looks deflated as she goes about her duties. I guess I would too in her situation.
Paloma’s husband passed away many years ago and she now shuts herself off from the world in her small apartment. Her greatest satisfaction seems to come from reading classic novels and eating chocolate. It’s a lonely existence and you can’t help but feel sorry for her.
Things change when an elderly Japanese man named Kakuro (Igawa) moves into an upper floor in the apartment building. When the pair are introduced, Paloma unknowingly borrows a line from one of her favourite novels – Anna Karenina. Kakuro picks up on the literary reference and he develops a curious fascination with Palmoa. He realises that there’s more to her than meets the eye.
Caught in between is a strange young girl named Renée (Balasko). She may only be 11-years-old but she’s incredibly intelligent. She has an awkward relationship with her parents and spends most of her time sneaking around and filming people using her video camera. Renée has made the decision to commit suicide on her 12th birthday. She’s started a countdown and plans are put into place.
I have mixed feelings about The Hedgehog. I liked the growing relationship with Paloma and Kakuro. They share some beautiful moments together – particularly in the final third of the film. It’s not explicitly spelt out with words but you know exactly what’s going through Paloma’s mind. Given her insecure nature, she’s hesitant of Kakuro and his intentions. Why would a wealthy guy like him be interested in a simple cleaner like her? That said, she can’t help but be pulled in by his friendly demeanour.
On the flip side, I was somewhat disturbed by Renée storyline. I actually thought she’d have more involvement with Kakuro and Paloma but her story seems almost secondary to the main attraction. I found her hard to relate to and struggled to understand why someone so young would be so calculating in planning her own demise. Put simply, I just didn’t like her.
I feel old when I realise that director Mona Achache is just 29 years of age. I hope I haven’t left it too late to one day direct a film of my own. The Hedgehog isn’t a bad effort for a first feature but I believe its focus on Renée’s character was the wrong approach.
I Am Love
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Luca Guadagnino |
Written by: | Luca Guadagnino, Barbara Alberti, Ivan Cotroneo, Walter Fasano |
Starring: | Tilda Swinton, Flavio Parenti, Edoardo Gabbriellini, Alba Rohrwacher, Pippo Delbono, Diane Fleri |
Released: | June 24, 2010 |
Grade: | A |
I can’t help but smile when I think of the many ways that I Am Love will divide audiences. At tonight’s preview screening, at least 12 people had walked out by the end. I’ve also read a few forums on the IMDB with some calling it “hopelessly pretentious” and “massively disappointing”.
If you want my opinion (and you’re about to get it), I think this a beautiful film. It reminded me in many ways of Tom Ford’s A Single Man which starred Colin Firth. It features creative cinematography, a booming film score, and a noticeable lack of dialogue. It’s the kind of movie where you observe the characters rather than listen to them.
The film is set in Italy and is about an incredibly wealthy family who own a large textile company. Due to his failing health, the head of the company is stepping down. He’s leaving control to his loyal son and, in somewhat of a surprise, to one of his grandsons. Will they be able to take the company forward and protect the family name?
Central to the story is the wife of the new chairman. Her name is Emma Recchi (Swinton) and she was born and raised in Russia. She’s an interesting character to follow. I don’t want to reveal too much about the story but events take place which leave her with much to think about. They question her attachment to her lifestyle and her loyalty to her family.
Throughout the whole film, I found myself analysing every single character. The film doesn’t explicitly tell us what they’re thinking. Even some factual details are left out (such as information on the “race” which the grandson competes in). It’s designed to challenge the audience and I applaud director Luca Guadagnino for his boldness.
What I’ll remember most about I Am Love is its striking visuals. From the opening credits to the closing credits, this is special stuff. It may appear random at times (with its abrupt editing and forever changing camera angles) but you get the sense that every single shot has been carefully thought out. John Adams score also deserves praise and will soon find a place in my soundtrack collection.
I see over 200 films a year and I’m always impressed when something comes along which is outside the "norm". I Am Love does just that and I hope you’re one of the lucky few who appreciates it.
The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | David Slade |
Written by: | Melissa Rosenberg |
Starring: | Kristen Stewart, Robert Pattinson, Taylor Lautner, Anna Kendrick, Billy Burke, Xavier Samuel, Bryce Dallas Howard |
Released: | July 1, 2010 |
Grade: | B |
I guess the obvious place to start is by comparing this latest instalment of the Twilight series with the two previous movies. It’s a thought process that will go through the minds of many as they leave the cinema. My official statement is as follows – it’s not as good as the first film but it’s better than the second film. Make of that as you will.
The premise in this fresh adventure is fairly simple. The nasty Victoria (Howard) is looking to avenge the death of her lover (who met an untimely end in the original movie). She’s put together an army of vampires led by newcomer Riley (played by Australian Xavier Samuel). They’re out to destroy Edward’s (Pattinson) life by killing his own true love, Bella (Stewart).
On your normal weekday, vampires and werewolves are worst enemies. Not so here. They reluctantly unite in a concerted effort to protect Bella from her would be attackers. They are also concerned about their own welfare. If these evil vampires continue their killing spree, the world will soon become aware of their existence.
These were the more interesting elements to the story. Once again, I felt let down by the film’s romantic side. It occurred to me late in the piece that I just didn’t care about Edward, Bella and to a lesser extent, Jacob (Lautner). It’s a cute love triangle but the way they all speak to each other is so dreary and tiring. They lack passion. There’s no spontaneity. I just wanted to see them have fun – to make me believe they had feelings for each other.
We’ve got another new director this time with Englishman David Slade (30 Days Of Night, Hard Candy) stepping into the hot seat. I wouldn’t say there’s a noticeable difference from the previous films but I did like his action climax. It’s not drawn out and it’s easy to follow what’s going on.
The stage is now set for the fourth and final film. Hang on. It turns out that that Stephenie Meyer’s last novel is going to be broken up into two movies. It seems Summit Entertainment has borrowed the idea from Warner Brothers and the Harry Potter series. I can’t blame them. There’s profit to be made… and a zillion teenage girls around the world will be lining up to hand over their pocket money from tomorrow morning.