Reviews


Directed by: Guy Ritchie
Written by:Michael Robert Johnson, Anthony Peckham, Simon Kinberg
Starring: Robert Downey Jr, Jude Law, Rachel McAdams, Mark Strong, Eddie Marsan, Kelly Reilly, Hans Matheson
Released: December 26, 2009
Grade: B-

Sherlock Holmes (Downey Jr) has done it again.  With the help of loyal assistant, Dr John Watson (Law), they have captured Lord Blackwood (Strong), a crafty serial killer who practices the “dark arts”.  Lord Blackwood is sent to the gallows and the people of London can now sleep much easier.  Case closed.

If you think that Holmes is going to celebrate this success… then think again.  With no major mysteries left to be solved, Holmes is bored and depressed.  He’s couped himself up in his home and shut himself off from the rest of the world.  To make matters worse, Watson has announced his engagement to a young lady named Mary (Reilly) and has told Holmes that he’s retiring from the dangerous world of sleuthing.

Never fear.  Things are about to get a lot more interesting for Holmes and Watson.  Word is spreading that Lord Blackwood has returned from the grave.  How can this be?  They both saw him hang and Watson declared him dead after checking his pulse.  Not all is what it seems and the dynamic duo must work together again to solve one final case.

Let’s start with the positives and the clear standout is the performance of Robert Downey Jr.  He breathes life into Holmes with his funny expressions and quirky mannerisms.  He also brings the best out of Jude Law (who I’ve been a bit iffy about in recent years).  A friend at the preview screening had similar thoughts and declared that “the reason I enjoyed Sherlock Holmes is that I didn’t hate Jude Law.”   They are some powerful words.

I must quickly digress to comment on Robert Downey Jr and his film career.  After battling substance abuse problems in the late 1990s, he “reinvented” himself and is now one of the world’s top box-office drawcards.  Iron Man was one of the biggest hits of 2008 and his role in Tropic Thunder earned him an Academy Award nomination (which is not easy to do for a comedic performance).  Downey Jr is not afraid of low-budget, independent films either and you only need see Kiss Kiss Bang Bang or A Scanner Darkly as evidence.

Back to Sherlock Holmes and whilst I can’t fault Downey Jr, I’m not a fan of the storyline.  It’s a rather dark plot – like something out of a Dan Brown novel.  Holmes also as an uncanny ability to fit the pieces of the puzzle together with ridiculous ease – again, like something out of a Dan Brown novel.  Perhaps my expectations were misguided but I was hoping for something less serious, more humorous.

Englishman Guy Ritchie sits in the director’s chair and many will be familiar with his style having seen such films as Snatch and Lock, Stock & Two Smoking Barrels.  This movie has its fair share of action but perhaps the most talked about element will be the relationship between Holmes and Watson.  I wasn’t familiar with the term before but I now I have an understanding of a “bromance”.

Every year, there’s always one huge release on Boxing Day to entertain the public and/or to help them get over their hangovers.  Sherlock Holmes is the 2009 contender and I’m sure there’ll be some long queues at cinemas over the coming days.

     


Directed by: Peter Jackson
Written by:Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, Peter Jackson
Starring: Saoirse Ronan, Rachel Weisz, Mark Whalberg, Susan Sarandon, Stanley Tucci, Amanda Michalka
Released: December 26, 2009
Grade: B-

On a winter afternoon in December 1973, 14-year-old Susie Salmon (Ronan) was walking home from school.  She bumped into George Harvey (Tucci), an odd looking man who had recently moved into a house just up the street.  Susie Salmon was never seen again.

This isn’t a traditional “who done it” movie.  As members of the audience, we know that Susie was murdered and that Mr. Harvey is the man responsible.  The question is – will he be caught?  George has done his best to cover his tracks but Susie’s father, Jack (Wahlberg) is unrelenting in his quest for answers.   He still harbours a faint hope that Susie is still alive and won’t stop until he knows the truth.

There’s someone else who is looking to expose the truth… Susie herself!  She is no longer living but she is yet to move on to heaven.  Susie has found herself in the “in-between”.  Like a ghost, she can subtly communicate with the living world, trying to point them in the direction of her murderer.

I had high expectations given the reputation of Peter Jackson and the alluring trailer.  Sadly, most of the film was a let down.  It feels as if every second page of Alice Sebold’s novel has been ripped out and the writers have somehow tried to reconstruct the story.

Jackson has created a cool fantasy world filled with great special effects but the character development is non-existent.  I had no appreciation for the grief that Susie’s parents were going through.  Her grandmother (played by Susan Sarandon) adds nothing to the story and yet they show her cleaning the house is a silly montage.

The same can be said for Susie’s siblings.  There’s a ludicrous scene late in the film where the sister hesitates about revealing a valuable piece of information.  My first question is why the hesitation?  My second question is why did she change face so quickly?

As the villain, Stanley Tucci (Julie & Julia) delivers the only decent performance.  I still thought he was a touch over the top (he looks like such an obvious creep) but the scene in which he lures Susie into his trap was the film’s best.  It’s creepy and hard to stomach.

With an ending just too convenient to take seriously, The Lovely Bones is the weakest Peter Jackson film I’ve seen to date.

     

 
Directed by: Jorge Blanco
Written by:Spike Jonze, Dave Eggers
Starring: Dwayne Johnson, Jessica Biel, Justin Long, Gary Oldman, Seann William Scott, John Cleese
Released: December 10, 2009
Grade: B

On a recent episode of At The Movies, Margaret Pomeranz says that she divides animated films into two categories – “animation ordinaire” and “animation that really is a notch above”.  It’s an apt way of summing up my own thoughts on the genre.  I’m usually “ok” with most animated films but I love those which have a rich, well thought out story.  Recent examples would include Up, Coraline, WALL-E and Ratatouille.

Planet 51 is a decent film but it’s not in the premiere league.  It’s the tale of an astronaut named Captain Charles T. Baker (Johnson) who lands on a planet which he thought to be uninhabited.  Instead, it finds it filled with cute-looking green aliens who speak English and live in a manner similar to our own (for reasons which are never explained – probably because there is no explanation).

The alien army seizes his spacecraft but he himself evades capture.  He meets a friendly alien named Lem (Long) who agrees to help him.  Lem realises that this human isn’t here to take over the planet or destroy their species.  He has come in peace.  The two must now devise a plan to get Lem back on his spacecraft and return home before it is too late.

It’s light-hearted stuff which kids should enjoy.  Justin Long is the best of the cast and I think makes a nice, likeable character out of Lem.  John Cleese seems to feature in so many animated films these days (Valiant, Shrek, Igor) but I never get tired of his antics.  Here, he does what he does best – playing an eccentric professor who thinks he’s an alien expert.

On the downside, there was potential to take this concept a lot further.  The idea of a human finding himself immersed in an alien world is the flip-side of so many other movies which have been made.  It’s all rather conservative but I admit to chuckling at a few of the pop culture references.  I don’t think I’ll be seeing it again but it was worth a look.

     


Directed by: Pedro Almodovar
Written by:Pedro Almodovar
Starring: Penelope Cruz, Lluis Homar, Blanca Portillo, Jose Luis Gomez, Ruben Ochandiano, Tamar Novas
Released: December 17, 2009
Grade: B+

With Avatar expected to dominate ticket sales this weekend, most studios are laying low in the lead up to Christmas.  The only other film being released on Thursday is Broken Embraces, the latest from acclaimed Spanish director Pedro Almodovar.  He has two Oscars on his mantelpiece at home and his most popular works include All About My Mother and Talk To Her.

I have an appreciation for the way in Almodovar develops his characters.  Things are rare black and white – there’s plenty of grey to keep things interesting.  Broken Embraces is no exception.  It begins with a blind man named Harry (Homar) befriending a young lady on the street.  She comes back to his house and they make love on the couch.  Should I see Harry as a sleazy womaniser?  Or should I feel sorry for Harry given his disability?  Things are grey already.

Harry hasn’t always been blind.  He was once a screenwriter and a filmmaker.  The story behind his condition will be revealed in flashbacks.  Fourteen years earlier, he was directing a movie with a young starlet named Lena (Cruz).  Harry was smitten with Lena from the first time he laid eyes on her.  Unfortunately, she was already taken by the film’s producer.  Ernesto Martel (Gomez) was an older, wealthier man who could give Lena whatever she wanted.

Pedro Almodovar has made better films than this.  I liked it generally but wasn’t blown away as I have been with previous works.  I found the ending somewhat predictable and a few scenes tended to drag out the inevitable.  Of particular annoyance was a character by the name of Ray X (Ochandiano) who is laughable as opposed to sinister.  I don’t think this was Almodovar’s intention.

The film is still worth seeing for its interesting assortment of characters and the difficult situations in which they find themselves.  Many are hiding secrets but which will be revealed?  And to whom?  I’ll leave it with you to figure out whilst I go and watch Avatar for a second time…

     

 
Directed by: Spike Jonze
Written by:Spike Jonze, Dave Eggers
Starring: Max Records, Catherine Keener, James Gandolfini, Chris Cooper, Forest Whitaker, Catherine O’Hara
Released: December 3, 2009
Grade: A-

I’ve often spoken about the difficulty of adapting a beloved novel for the big screen.  It’s hard to condense the material and the character development into a mere two hours.  That wasn’t the case with Where The Wild Things Are.  The picture book, written by Maurice Sendak and first published in 1963, contains just 10 sentences.  Screenwriters Spike Jonze and Dave Eggers found themselves in the odd position where they needed to build on the original story.

And what a great job they’ve done.  Jonze didn’t want to make a children’s film.  Instead, he “set out to make a movie about a childhood”.  The story’s protagonist is a 9-year-old boy named Max (played by Max Records in his first movie role).  Max is a typical kid at that age – fun-loving and adventurous yet immature and naive.  He’s also got a lot of strange feelings building up inside of him.

Max always wants to be the centre of attention and he gets frustrated when his mum and older sister don’t reciprocate.  One night, he runs away from home and finds himself in a strange fantasy world inhabited by large monsters.  They initially threaten to eat Max but he convinces them otherwise by telling them that he’s a king who has come to rule them.  The monsters have been looking for a leader for some time and they anoint Max by providing him a gold crown.

At first, everything is great.  Max receives all the attention he demands and he makes a bunch of new friends.  All the decisions he makes are fruitful.  He even helps the monsters establish a new home – a giant fort with a series of underground tunnels.

Ah, but it’s not always easy being the king.  These monsters are battling their own strange feelings of inadequacy and insecurity.  A division develops between some of them and Max doesn’t know how to make things right.  He’ll need to quickly learn from this fast-paced lesson in maturity or else he could end up as the monster’s next meal.  Max’s old life is taking on a much greater appreciation.

Spike Jonze is one of the world’s most gifted filmmakers and his credits include Being John Malkovich and Adaptation.  He gave himself a big challenge in taking Where The Wild Things Are to the big screen but Jonze was up to the task.  It’s a dazzling film to watch on the big screen – from the close ups of Max’s face (whose emotions are always showing) to the panoramic shots of this fantasy world.

 Let’s not forget the “wild things”.  If they all look very real to you… then that’s because they are.  They weren’t created with digitally.  The creature crew spent 8 months designing and building actual monster suits for actors to inhabit.  The only special effects are the monster’s faces – which were later altered to match up against the dubbed voices.  You won’t notice it at all.

The film could be quite scary in places for young children – a fact I have no problem with.  It’s nice to see a family-orientated movie that contains “fear” as part of its repertoire.  It’s a feeling that we all deal with and too often it is overlooked in films of a similar vein.

Shot on the southern coast of Australia just outside Melbourne, Where The Wild Things Are is a terrific movie for people of any age to enjoy.

     


Directed by: James Cameron
Written by:James Cameron
Starring: Sam Worthington, Zoe Saldana, Sigourney Weaver, Stephen Lang, Michelle Rodriguez, Giovanni Ribisi
Released: December 17, 2009
Grade: A

In 1997, director James Cameron “wowed” me with Titanic.  It was one of the greatest films ever made and it’s still the highest grossing film in U.S. history.  I’ve been waiting twelve long years for Cameron to make another movie.  Why has he taken so long?  Whatever the reason, the wait has been worth it.  Avatar is the most visually spectacular film that I’ve ever seen on a big screen.  The bar has been raised.

Set in the year 2154, an army of humans have travelled to a distant planet known as Pandora.  They are extracting a valuable mineral from the ground which is worth an astronomical sum back home.  Unfortunately, there is an alien race on Pandora known as the Na’vi.  The only way the minerals can be dug up is by displacing the Na’vi from their homes.  They don’t plan on doing so without a fight.

Not everyone aboard the human spaceship is interested in these rocks.  A small team of peaceful scientists are looking to explore the planet to see what else can be learned from its people and its beautiful forests.  To help with their task, they have created avatars – a Na’vi body they can inhabit whilst on the surface.  It helps them communicate with the locals and in defending themselves against some vicious wildlife.

Caught in the middle is a paraplegic named Jake Sully (Worthington).  Jake is an ex war veteran who has been brought in to help the head scientist (Weaver) with her work.  Ah, but he’s also being used by the ship’s military leader (Lang) to gain valuable intelligence information on the Na’vi people and their weaknesses.  To whom do his allegiances really lie?

Not even Jake knows the answer to that question at first.  All he cares about is his amazing new life on Pandora.  Through his avatar, he now has the use of his legs for the first time in many years.  He has also developed affection for the planet and its people.  In particular, Jake has formed a bond with a young woman named Neytiri (Saldana) who is teaching him the ways of the Na’vi.

The dialogue is stiff at times but there’s an intricacy to the story which elevates it above your run-of-the-mill action flick.  This should come as no surprise given James Cameron’s history.  He loves visual effects but he recognises the importance of telling a good story.  Aliens, Terminator and Titanic are fitting examples.  In Avatar, he had me cheering for the strange-looking blue creatures instead of the humans.  Not necessarily an easy accomplishment.

Let’s be honest though – the reason this film is so amazing is because of its look.  The line separating live action and special effects has been blurred beyond recognition.  I didn’t know what was what.  Enhancing it even further is the fact it was filmed using the latest in 3D technology.  You will find yourself immersed in a fantasy world filled with a kaleidoscope of colours.  Or to put it more bluntly, in the words of Hollywood columnist Jeffrey Wells, “it's like your eyeballs are having sex.

Australian Sam Worthington must be pinching himself after the year he’s had.  Fresh off his role in Terminator: Salvation (where he was the best part of it), Worthington then got to star in a James Cameron movie.  Does it get any better?  You can see why Cameron chose him though.  Worthington gives a terrific performance.  With just a hint of his Aussie accent, he turns Jake into an ideal hero – someone a little rough around the edges but not lacking in passion.

It goes without saying that Avatar must be seen in 3D on the big screen.  It clocks in at just over two and a half hours and is sure to have cinemas packed once the word of mouth spreads.  Mr Cameron, please do not make me wait another twelve years for your next movie.