Welcome to the Film Pie! Brisbane based film critic Matt Toomey has reviewed thousands of movies since 1996. See what's out now, or browse the review archive.

Best & Worst Lists

Best Rank Worst
Requiem For A Dream 1 Glitter
Traffic 2 Ghosts Of Mars
LOTR: The Fellowship Of The Ring 3 Head Over Heels
Nurse Betty 4 Freddie Got Fingered
Memento 5 Crocodile Dundee In L.A.
Almost Famous 6 Book Of Shadows: Blair Witch
The Pledge 7 Dungeons & Dragons
Moulin Rouge 8 The Forsaken
You Can Count On Me 9 Scary Movie 2
A.I. 10 Heartbreakers

Total films reviewed - 158
Best Rank Worst
Billy Elliot 1 Kevin & Perry Go Large
Magnolia 2 Down To You
American Beauty 3 Urban Legends: Final Cut
The Insider 4 Boys And Girls
Topsy-Turvy 5 Mission To Mars
The Grinch 6 Deuce Bigalow
Wonder Boys 7 The Next Best Thing
Frequency 8 Dudley Do-Right
The Talented Mr. Ripley 9 The Bachelor
The Cider House Rules 10 The Thirteenth Warrior

Total films reviewed - 168

At the end of each year, I take great pleasure in compling a list of the best and worst films from the last 12 months. It provides "closure". I can encapsulate the cinematic year by listing 10 exceptional films and 10 horrendous films. It's fun looking back at years past and it can provide a good reference point when comparing year to year. Of the more than 6,000 films that I have reviewed, my favourite is Billy Elliot.

Here then are the links to my best and worst lists from 1996 to the current date. You can click on each year for the full list. Are there some films that you haven't seen before? If so, get off your butt and watch them!
 

Year Best Film
1996 Romeo & Juliet
1997 Titanic
1998 The Sweet Hereafter
1999 Being John Malkovich
2000 Billy Elliot
2001 Requiem For A Dream
2002 Mulholland Drive
2003 Chicago
2004 Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind
2005 Million Dollar Baby
2006 Capote
2007 The Lives Of Others
2008 Juno
2009 The Wrestler
2010 Inception
2011 Another Year
2012 Shame
2013 Life Of Pi
2014 Boyhood
2015 Inside Out
2016 Brooklyn
2017 Call Me by Your Name
2018 Phantom Thread
2019 If Beale Street Could Talk
2020 Never Rarely Sometimes Always
2021 Riders of Justice
2022 Everything Everywhere All at Once
2023 Close

 

Best Rank Worst
Being John Malkovich 1 Teaching Mrs. Tingle
Gods And Monsters 2 Entrapment
Election 3 Jawbreaker
Snow Falling On Cedars 4 Urban Legend
Pleasantville 5 Inspector Gadget
The Thin Red Line 6 Dead Man On Campus
Go 7 The Astronaut's Wife
Eyes Wide Shut 8 The Mummy
Bulworth 9 Wild Wild West
Shakespeare In Love 10 Baby Geniuses

Total films reviewed - 173
Best Rank Worst
The Sweet Hereafter 1 Tarzan & The Lost City
Saving Private Ryan 2 The Avengers
Mulan 3 Spice World: The Movie
Jackie Brown 4 The Second Jungle Book
Dark City 5 Mortal Kombat: Annihilation
Life Is Beautiful 6 Hope Floats
The Impostors 7 Money Talks
Deep Impact 8 I Still Know What You Did Last Summer
Good Will Hunting 9 Lost In Space
Primary Colours 10 Welcome To Woop Woop

Total films reviewed - 176
Best Rank Worst
Titanic 1 The Stupids
The Ice Storm 2 Thinner
The People Vs. Larry Flynt 3 A Very Brady Sequel
Marvin's Room 4 High School High
Breaking The Waves 5 Fire Down Below
Face/Off 6 A Life Less Ordinary
L.A. Confidential 7 Diana And Me
Hamlet 8 The Glimmer Man
The English Patient 9 Romy & Michelle's High School Reunion
Mother 10 Buddy

Total films reviewed - 167
Best Rank Worst
Romeo & Juliet 1 The Crow: City Of Angels
Leaving Las Vegas 2 Homeward Bound 2
Fargo 3 Vampire In Brooklyn
Shine 4 Jingle All The Way
Mr. Holland's Opus 5 Sunset Park
Secrets And Lies 6 Dead Man
Hoop Dreams 7 Screamers
Dead Man Walking 8 The Quest
Ransom 9 Maximum Risk
Copycat 10 The Juror

  Total films reviewed - 167